At a community meeting in Toronto last month, a police officer recommended that residents leave their key fobs at their front door to avoid a violent confrontation with car thieves. The advice garnered backlash online, and some social media posts claimed authorities were now encouraging people to place their fobs on the porch. This is false. Police never suggested that residents should leave their keys outside their doors. One of the posts that drew the most eyeballs also claimed police in Canada said footage of "home invaders" recorded on owners鈥 property violates criminals鈥 privacy rights. This is misleading. A Quebec police officer said in January that posting 鈥 as opposed to simply recording 鈥 the video online could breach privacy rules. Additionally, the lieutenant spoke only for that jurisdiction, rather than a Canada-wide one.
on X, formerly known as Twitter, claimed police urged Torontonians to put their key fobs on their porches or outside their doors for auto thieves to take. Two tweets alone garnered more than 390,000 views, as of publication. One claimed police instructed residents to 鈥渓eave your Key Fob on the front porch so criminals don't have to break into your home to steal your car!鈥 Another claimed police said people should 鈥渓eave our car keys outside our doors so thieves don鈥檛 have to go to the trouble of breaking down your door.鈥
That second post also claimed that police warned residents not to record people taking objects from their property in acts of so-called porch piracy. The that contained the false key fob claim stated on X that 鈥減olice in Canada have told us that 鈥 CCTV footage ON YOUR PROPERTY violates the privacy rights of home invaders.鈥 poster in January sought to paraphrase authorities: 鈥淢ontreal police: don't take videos of thieves committing a federal offense.鈥
Rating: False/Misleading
The claim that police recommended putting key fobs on the porch is false. In the referred to in various posts, Toronto police Const. Marco Ricciardi advises attendees at a community meeting in Toronto鈥檚 Etobicoke neighbourhood in February to put key fobs at their front door, but not beyond it: 鈥淭o prevent the possibility of being attacked in your home, leave your fobs at your front door 鈥 because they鈥檙e breaking into your home to steal your car. They don鈥檛 want anything else.鈥
One news report said he recommended placing the keys in a Faraday pouch, an aluminum-lined bag that blocks the fob鈥檚 signal, to stymie auto thieves.
On March 13, the Toronto Police service posted a link to a to prevent home invasion in connection with auto theft. It also that an officer had recently suggested drivers leave their car keys in a Faraday bag by the front door. 鈥淲hile well meaning, there are better ways to prevent auto theft motivated home invasions,鈥 the post stated. The list of tips makes no mention of key fobs.
The officer鈥檚 initial advice on key fobs does seem to contradict tips from other agencies. The Peel Police Service, for example, said in a March 14 that 鈥渒eeping key fobs away from doorways and entrances鈥 would make it harder to steal vehicles.
Thieves often deploy equipment that captures the signal from a fob and amplifies it to unlock a vehicle, a process that may be stymied if the signal is farther away 鈥 in the back of the house, for example.
Posting about porch piracy
The claim that police warned against recording thieves on your property is misleading.
In a video call with CTV News in January, Quebec provincial police spokesman Lt. Benoit Richard : 鈥淵ou cannot post the images yourself because you have to remember that in Canada we have a presumption of innocence and posting that picture could be a violation of private life.鈥
The social media posts in question suggested that merely recording the video rather than posting it online was the issue. Further, one of the post's mention of "home invaders" is inaccurate, because the officer was discussing thefts from outside a residence, whereas home invasion refers to burglary via unlawful entrance into a residence 鈥 the building itself. (One of the two posts also incorrectly said the officer was with the Montreal police force rather than the Quebec provincial police.)
Whether the officer鈥檚 own claim is accurate is another question.
Asked if Quebecers have the right to record and post footage from their own home 鈥 including footage of people taking something from their property 鈥 the police service told The 春色直播 Press: 鈥淪ince your question is regarding a possible interpretation on a part of the Quebec civil code, we have to refer you to a civil law lawyer.鈥
David Fraser, an internet and privacy lawyer with McInnes Cooper, said the officer鈥檚 suggestion of privacy breaches or defamation is basically groundless.
鈥淭he officer in that case is categorically incorrect and, I assume, ill-informed,鈥 Fraser said in a phone interview.
鈥淎s an individual, you have an unrestricted right to record anything on your property, subject to criminal laws related to voyeurism and things like that that are certainly not applicable on your porch 鈥 and particularly not applicable with respect to uninvited visitors on your porch.鈥
Aside from using that footage for commercial purposes, such as an advertisement, few if any restrictions on public posting apply, Fraser said.
Even defamation is a dubious concern in this case, he continued.
鈥淎s long as the video has not been altered in order to create a false impression, defamation law really doesn't come into play.鈥
Libel and slander revolve around harming someone鈥檚 reputation.
鈥淎nd certainly if you're a porch pirate and somebody calls you a porch pirate, that's going to harm your reputation. But truth is an absolute defence to defamation.鈥
However, there may be some exceptions if written or verbal accusations that accompany a video post stem from misunderstandings or incorrect claims.
鈥淚 had a package that was accidentally delivered to my neighbour 鈥 So I went over to my neighbour's house and I retrieved my package,鈥 Fraser said. 鈥漀ow, if my neighbour had a camera on her porch and was expecting a package that day that wasn't delivered and had posted, 鈥極h my God, does anybody recognize this guy? He stole a package from my porch?鈥 That might cross into defamation, maybe. But that's a total edge case,鈥 he said.
Sources
Claims about police advice on key fobs can be found on X (, ) and ()
Claims about porch pirate footage can be found on X () and ()
()
()
()
()
()
About 春色直播 Press fact checks
You can find out more about 春色直播here and about 春色直播 Press Fact Checks here. To reach our fact-checking team with any tips, corrections or comments, please email us at cpfactcheck@thecanadianpress.com.
